DA taking ‘creative’ approach to staffing crunch; seeks to add paralegal/evidence techs
Saying his deputy prosecutors are so snowed under paperwork that it can affect the evidence process in legal cases, District Attorney Seth Ryan intends a “creative solution” that will also help with his recruitment and retention challenges.
Ryan is proposing to use part of his budgetary allotment from the six counties of the 7th Judicial District to hire three people for full-time paralegal/evidence tech positions: one for Delta County Court and one each for Montrose County and Montrose District courts.
The goal, as Ryan told Montrose County commissioners in a brief presentation on Oct. 19, is “to have someone act as data managers for our cases, rather than ask our attorneys.”
The district attorney is an elected official, not a county employee. By law, the counties in a judicial district kick in money for the DA’s annual budget based on their individual populations. The 7th Judicial District consists of Montrose, Delta, Gunnison, San Miguel, Ouray, and Hinsdale counties.
The proposed contribution for Montrose County in 2024 is $1.37 million — about $122,000 more than for 2023 — of the total $3.3 million sought collectively from all 7th Judicial District counties.
“A lot of DAs across the state have paralegals to help them manage caseloads and help attorneys prepare for trials and organize the evidence in a case for the attorneys to help them at trial,” Ryan said.
“We’re not a small county anymore. My office is growing. We have the public safety tax that was approved for the sheriff’s office, but we’re not part of the public safety tax, so we have to find ways to meet the increase and capacity that we’re seeing, especially in county court, where we’re seeing the biggest increase in cases.”
Montrose County voters in 2007 approved a 0.75% public safety sales tax, the lion’s share of which goes to the sheriff’s office, as per the ballot language. Thirty percent of the revenue can be used at the county commissioners’ discretion for matters related to public safety.
But as cases are growing, Ryan’s staff isn’t. Right now, most of his deputy prosecutors have to take on a good portion of the data management their cases entail. That’s not working, Ryan explained.
“We have three attorneys in Montrose County court, we probably could use four attorneys. We have two attorneys in Delta; we could probably use three attorneys,” he noted.
“But I think someone specializing in reviewing that evidence is going to help take some of the burden off our attorneys to manage the data managers and let them get back to their jobs as attorneys.”
(Deputy district attorneys also operate in district-level courts; some operate in both county and district courts.)
When a case is filed, prosecutors are by law required to provide to defense counsel all evidence (discovery) law enforcement collects. If that is not done within the required time, there can be sanctions up to and including suppression of evidence or even case dismissal.
“I think law enforcement is increasingly asking their officers to be data managers as well. So sometimes we’re missing stuff — and when I say sometimes, I mean oftentimes we’re missing stuff. So someone has to go through the case with a fine tooth comb to make sure we have everything that law enforcement has generated and that we provide that to defense,” Ryan said.
“With the increase in electronic evidence, body camera footage, our attorneys just don’t have the time and capacity.”
Hiring someone to do that and then be the liaison between his office and law enforcement is “absolutely critical,” Ryan added.
Staffing and retention are issues nationally, Ryan said, but in the 7th Judicial District, the issues are exacerbated by the challenge of attracting people to move to — and stay in — rural areas. If a candidate knows he or she will have help from a paralegal or technician, that could be a factor in accepting a deputy prosecutor position.
Ryan told Montrose County commissioners that, although he has conducted interviews for prospective hires, many do not graduate until spring. Previously, he has sent offers, only to learn that all but one candidate had already gotten a job somewhere else by the time he was able to make the offer.
“You’ve gotta jump fast,” Ryan said.
The commissioners appeared to favor Ryan’s plan, with board chair Sue Hansen calling it “a creative way to maximize your staff.”
The Montrose County 2024 budget is undergoing departmental reviews. A public hearing on the final document is planned for December.
Katharhynn Heidelberg is the Montrose Daily Press assistant editor and senior writer.
Montrose Daily Press | October 25, 2023
Print or download article