Ouray County Sexual-Assault Cases Winding Through Judicial System

September 21, 2017 — Since 2015, five sexual-assault cases with Ouray County connections have been making their way through the criminal justice system. Three of the alleged incidents feature former area officials, including former Ridgway Assistant Fire Chief Travis Buck, former Ridgway Planning Commission Chairman Brian Scranton, and former business owner and veterinarian Joseph Alaimo.

Buck entered a plea agreement Aug. 31 on a “sexual assault with a 10-year age difference” charge, and was sentenced to 18 months of unsupervised probation. The charge will be dismissed if Buck successfully fulfills all plea agreement requirements, including registering as a sex offender and not  being around children under the age of 18 (other than his own). Jail time is a possibility if Buck doesn’t fully comply.

At the hearing, the underage victim’s mother said her daughter had been “manipulated” by Buck, according to a Ouray County Plaindealer article in the Sept. 7-13, 2017, edition. “She’s so well manipulated, she doesn’t feel she was victimized,” the mother said during the hearing. “Do not downplay the severity of this crime.”

In the case of Scranton, the trial was rescheduled earlier this month to Jan. 28, 2018. Scranton has pleaded not guilty to the charges: one count of sexual assault as a Class 3 felony and one count of sexual assault as a Class 4 felony. The allegations stem from a May 2015 incident in which a woman claims she was sexually assaulted during a party at his house.

Alaimo — who moved to Pennsylvania after closing his Ouray County business, Trail Town Still, in December 2015 — has been charged with second-degree assault/drugging a victim, sexual assault/victim incapable of appraising conditions and sexual assault on a helpless victim.

There are two alleged victims in the case, including one whom Alaimo allegedly sexually assaulted during a May 2015 incident at his former business.

Alaimo’s trial is expected to be scheduled during an Oct. 2 court hearing.

In another case, a sex-sting operation earlier this year resulted in five arrests, including four Montrose residents and one Ouray County local. Daniel Leonardi, of Ouray County, was charged with criminal attempt, internet luring, solicitation of child prostitution, contributing to the delinquency of a minor, patronizing a child prostitute and pandering of a child, the Plaindealer has reported.

Another Ouray County-related case resulting from the sting operation involves Montrose resident Nicholas Love — who was formerly employed as a Ridgway School District custodian. Love has been charged with attempted sex assault on a child and internet luring of a child with intent to exploit, among several other charges.

Both cases are at different stages in the court system.

The sting which led to Love and Leonardi’s arrest was organized by the Montrose Police Department, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Colorado Bureau of Investigation, Colorado State Patrol, Montrose County Sheriff’s Office, Delta County Sheriff’s Office, Delta Police Department and 7th Judicial District Attorney’s Office.

Following community scrutiny surrounding the cases, Ouray County law-enforcement officials, including Sheriff Dominic Mattivi and Chief Justin Perry, organized a public meeting in July regarding advocacy resources available to victims.

Perry, who also is Ouray’s interim city administrator, told The Watch that the county will receive more than $40,000 in a Victim Assistance and Law Enforcement grant to fund a part-time victim’s advocate and victim’s services program in 2018.

“It’s really going to be an incredible program,” Perry said. “I’m excited for it. The resource is going to be awesome.”

The advocate and program will be for all law enforcement agencies in the county, Perry added. For the past four years, Perry has secured funds to support a victim’s service program. He said his department has received “excellent feedback” about the program.

“It’s one of the most critical and important services we can provide and we can have in our police department and our county,” he said.

A part-time advocate was last available in 2015. For the past two years, it’s been more of an on-call service, Perry explained. When Perry joined the department in 2013, there was no such program, he said.

Law-enforcement agencies aren’t required to have an advocate under the state’s Victim Rights Act, but must provide victims with information about community services, such as applicable protection and assistance resources. A full list of crime victim rights can be viewed on the state’s official website (colorado.gov) under the Department of Public Safety Division of Criminal Justice section.

Sherry McKenzie, public information Officer of the 7th Judicial District Attorney’s Office, said the Office and District Attorney Dan Hotsenpiller are aware of the cases, but declined to provide any further details. She added that all cases that are brought to the Office’s attention are done so by local “law-enforcement partners.”

“We will not have knowledge of any unreported cases or cases that may be under investigation by a law-enforcement agency,” she said.

When asked if the Office would participate in community outreach efforts regarding sexual assault, McKenzie did not comment.

Ridgway resident and sexual-assault victim Heather Toth has continually spoken out in support of better advocacy for victims in Ouray County.

She’s also publicly supported the alleged victims in the Alaimo case.

“There are several components required to combat sexual assault and challenges that accompany these crimes,” she wrote in a letter to the editor for the May 4-10, 2017, issue of the Ouray County Plaindealer. “Community education, law-enforcement training and emotional support for the victims are just a few of these components. Halting victim blaming and believing victims is another.”

Watch Contributor Tanya Ishikawa assisted with this story.

Written by Justin Criado, Senior Staff Writer
The Watch | September 21, 2017
Print or download original article

2017-11-03T11:26:39+00:00